Friday, February 1, 2013

Shades of love on Gurudutt’s Canvas

Love is increasingly becoming risqué- taking in bollywood . But the same bollywood will always be obliged to the work of Vasanth Kumar Shivashankar Padukone popularly known as Guru Dutt. In remembrance of Guru Dutt, IAAN Express commemorates one of the most acknowledged work on celluloid -“Pyasa”. 

 “Pyasa” is the journey of a poet who is struggling to get recognition from the world. The world continuously declines Vijay which was played by Gurudutt himself with utmost conviction. He lived the tragedy relentlessly and absorbed the disgust. His pain convinces the audience. Unlikely, Vijay never broke into tears or blasted into anger during rejections. He accepts all thrust upon him. His eyes nethier got red nor got filled with salty water. He neither blamed destiny nor the world. His patience and persistence evokes the love which was inspirational but unrealizable. The character of Vijay is devoid of any kind of violence and gimmick. When pain became unsustainable all agonies imbibed into poetry. It was the same poetry which failed to reach to the acclaimers. Vijay gets an admirer as Gulab. Wahida Rehman impressively gets in the character of Gulab. This was a bold attempt to shatter the perceived image of a Heroine in that era. She played the role of a prostitute with dignity. At any stage no one can find the objectionable cheapness in her performance. She is immensely beautiful in the deglamorised role. As Vijay grew on the audience mind because of irrefutable pain Gulab settled in the heart of same with her unconditional love. Meena the lady love of Vijay played by Mala Sinha rejects him for being poor and unsuccessful. She regrets on her decision. The rich man to whom she gets married gives him all but not the love she wanted. Meena was an unsatisfactory and helpless, almost dejected by her husband. She cannot break the golden shackles neither she could be with his love. Relation and encounters between Meena and Vijay cannot be perceived as extra marital affair. The three central characters of “Pyasa” are derived from love. Three of them keeps urging for the love which is not in their destiny. They all choose harsh destiny.

Pyasa created in 1959 still makes sense in 2013. It is a painful story of unending suffering experienced by Gurudutt as Vijay. Gurudutt as a director holds large canvas in which he draws all shades of love in all the characters he emulated from imagination. Vijay is poor and struggling poet who is patiently endeavouring to get recognition for his work. He had a widowed mother played by Leela Mishra and two elder brothers played by Mehmood and Radheyshyam. Just in few scenes of beginning gurudutt gains immense sympathy for Vijay. Vijay who had left his house because of his misery avoids to get caught by his mother who was desperate to see her wandering son. She takes Vjiay home where he was barbarically taunted for being a poet and eventually kicked off from house after a diatribe by his elder brothers. He lefts home in despair and leaves her mother there. Again Gurudutt the director amazingly conveys the emotional suffocation of helpless relation between Vijay and his mother. From here onwards audience experiences a rare romance which overflows from bleeding heart of Vijay and Gulab. Waheeda Rehman as Gulab tries to get naughty and cosy with expressions while in effort of catching Vijay. In the role of a prostitute, young and attractive Wahida Rehman doesn’t shed her cloth neither reveals her body. Gurudutt captures the appeal from Gulabs expressions in close shots and body movements which cannot be called dance, but just strolling through the street. In the song “ Baat Kuch Aisi Hui” Wahida Rehman wrapped in plain Sari delivers an unforgettable performance which is still iconic in its own terms. Well, that was not enough to tremble all the cords of emotion. Gurudutt introduces Vijays love interest from college days, Mala Sinha in the role of Meena. Meena is married to a rich and shrewd man with gloomy anger on face Mr. Ghosh played by Rehman. Vijay, Meena and Mr. Ghosh meets at the alumni association of college, where Vijays anguish gets expressions of barbed wire taunt poetry by seeing her beloved married to Mr Ghosh. Mr. Ghosh smells the smoke of Vijays burning heart for Meena and decides to take on his wife’s ex-lover. He offers him job at his publishing house, Vijay unknown to the fact that Ghosh is husband to Meena accepts the offer with the hope that his poetic creation wil get inked some day. Gurudutt have a powerful imagination of creating impressionable scenes. In the party scene at the house of Mr. Ghosh where Vijay is made to do slavery not knowing that this is the house of his married beloved faces soft toned harsh insult shatters all the hearts sympathized with the protagonist. On the other hand Gulab, who was enthralled by the poetry of Vijay falls in love with him. She waits at the places where she can suppose off Vijay. The sudden transformation of her character from attractive and naughty into a wandering gloomy soul searching for Vijay was brilliantly personified. Gurudutt designs another encounter of Vijay and Gulab. Gulab who was searching for a customer was chased by policeman. During her chase she colloids and get embraced to Vijay. She pleads him to save her from being caught. On asked by policeman he acknowledges Gulab as his wife. As acknowledgement pours into the years of Gulab, she surrenders herself to Vijay completely. She gets devoted to Vijay with inadmissible love. Mighty hearted Vijay who imprisons all sobs all this long finally breaks into tears when he gets the news of his mother’s death. No loving son can survive the pain of mother’s death. Vijay fails to contest against this dejection from destiny and ends up at alchohol. Every time when Vijay’s heart bleed unexpressed hate and anger freezed into poetry for the world which continuously rejected him, this time it “Jinhe Naaz Hai Hind Par Wo Kaha Hain”. Gulab holds hand of lost Vijay and shares his grief, inspires the man she loves to live for poetry and her lady love Meena. Vijay being in an unfortunate accident while saving a beggars life, suffers mental injury and beggar dies but news of Vijay’s death spreads. Gurudutt, the Maestro of capturing emotions emulates how the two ladies who are in love with Vijay conceive the death news of him? Mr. Ghosh gets relentlessly emotionless when he reads out death news aloud deliberately from news paper for his wife who is carrying soft corner for Vijay. In another scene Gulab who is just about to apply sindoor gets news and shatters. She gets windowed even without getting married. Gulab decides to publish the poems of Vijay. She takes his poetry collection to the publishing house of Mr.Ghosh. Mr. Ghosh finally publishes poetry collection of Vijay which becomes an outrageous hit. The fact that the creator of gem of a collection is no more sympathises readers more and lures friends and elder brothers of Vijay. Vijay gets the deserved recognition after his death. Drama does not end here. More harsh reality of world unfolds on celluloids as climax starts building from Gurudutts understanding. Vijay appears from nowhere and witness the world recognizing and admiring his work. Since he is dead to people, he saw how people try to relate with him to get recognized. Stark realties of human made relations are painful and gets nastier yet loving as it is seen through the spectacles of Gurudutt.  Finally, when the world recognizes and hails him, he rejects it.He punishes the world by not availing the poet in him to the needy world. As the celluloid journey of Pyasa reaches destination Vijay gets the true love in Gulab. “Pyasa” is an unparallel work of Maestro who in real life also lived like Vijay.   
Pyasa will loose its emotions in subtraction Sahir Ludhiyavis powerful and painful poetic lyrics. SD Burmans original tunes makes lyrics seep deep in heart. Intelligent use of spot lights at crucial stages adds divinity to the character of Vijay especially in the song "Tang Aa Chuke Hain Kashm-e-Kashe Zindagi Se" in the climax. Mohd. Rafi gets four songs and creates the melody in pain. "Sar Jo Tera Chakraye" is a funny song and perfectly enacted by Johny Walker was huge hit then and tremendously used from movies to commercials even now.  Hemant Kumars lends voice to "Jane Woh Kaise Log", a situational song in which Vijay realises that Meena is married to Mr. Ghosh. Legendary singer Geeta does playback for all the songs pictured on Wahida Rehman and Mala Sinha. Geeta Dutts magical voice relishes in "Jaane Kya Tune Kahi" and in the Duet song with Mohd Rafi in romantic song "Ham Aapki Aankhon Me". Pyasa is complete package which touches every emotion of love. It is a master piece by a maestro of expressing love on celluloid.  When love is expressed on screen with acceptable intimacy and sometime with limitless intimacy, it is necessary to remind that there was a filmmaker who found romance in hardships and tragedies of life. Gurudutts romance was infinite and incompetent. Gurudutts camera captured intimacy of emotions instead of physical intimacy. He conquered in trembling thought space and provoking emotions of positivity instead of titillating. His heroines were never just symbolic. His story narration is incomplete without woman in central position. His stories were not gender oriented. Each character has its own gravity. He used high quality literary work in songs and dialogues which was not less than collection gems. Gurudutt was a rare combination of film making attributes of high quality.                                                       If filmmaking is an art then Gurudutt will always be the most exquisite artist. His understanding and courage of sketching characters on celluloid was a metaphor in itself. Among all the emotions that he successfully stimulated in the heart of audience was romance. He was so natural with his approach that audience have rarely seen protagonist embracing beloved and yet he made felt what he wanted. “Pyasa” one of his most acclimatised creation got space in TIMES MAGAZINE in the list of all time romantic movies ever made. Pyasa is not just romantic story. It is about sustaining anguish of undeserved failure. 

Who will decide moral values?

 Freedom, Choice and Law of land

Rise in heinous crimes against women and recent public protest across the nation fired up debate to rethink over the freedom which we inherited.  Who will decide moral values? This is the question often being tossed nowadays by the librated thinkers of society. There can be no cause correct which justify crimes like Rape. Modern culture as seen in metro cities which reaches in its weird version to emerging towns is also making conservative class of society worried. As said by Rabindernath Tagore, We have borrowed the spectacles but lost the sight.

India is probably only democratic country in real sense where protestors are not dealt brutally on the name of mob controlling. Delhi gang rape which grabbed the attention of globe and followed by upheaval took off from protest by mass comprised of youth, forced the policy makers and administrators to articulate strict laws. Various committees are set up and are in progress of reconstruction of laws which should sleek in society and create safety for women and fear for criminal. This is intrigue to uncover the fact that economic development which we enjoyed after Liberalization has something to do with the sexual crimes. Liberalized economic policies not only imported investment but also got ultra modern culture for free. Things which we get for free often don’t have significant value but depending on users brain can be utilized. Western life style and culture which is continuously blamed by politicians and conservative society, has succeeded in touching the lives of all in one way or other. Women are deprived and victimized in India before liberalization despite of laws and regulations. Does those micro-minis attract rapist mind. Instead of checking the ingredients of culture curry why not look once at the ethical and moral part of day to day life.    
Generation next which demands for free way culture is ideologically confronting with those who thinks that they have protected and preserved the moral values. If it is rightly so accepted, then why there is a huge disproportionate difference in male to female sex ration. Why there is rise in youth addiction? Why Vivekananda is an obsolete inspiration or an inspiration for a niche?  A woman which gets status of Goddess, to worship only is made to remain confined. Sometimes walls made of bricks and sometimes made of societal values. Much talked economic poverty should take metal poverty in the ambit. Gennext boys and girls who are brought up in free culture have developed the characteristic of not accepting “no”. This is the population which loves instant comments and likes, prefers instant food and instant formulas of success. Tolerance and persistence cannot be attributed to the urban youth largely dependent 3G speed. Conservative minds that are rigid on their principles are slow and steady, and are far behind as compared modern youth. Just take the example of Khap panchayats not considering their political power they do influence society of their remit. Khap panchayts have some sort public acceptance. Irrespective to their modus operandi their declarations are generally accepted by the masses they govern. That is why those voice are less and feeble which are against such legally unrecognized governing bodies. In modern society choice may have a limitless perspective but in small town, choice is as limited as having favorite street food once a week with family or friends. Popular actress can say that what if they walk naked on road, this is their choice. This choice is derived and shielded by right. Choice cannot be accounted on grounds morality, or can be. Do laws of land make people ethical and moral? Actually, laws are made to create fear. However, fear can control less empowered and very general, The common man. The middleclass of society have to bear the pressure of conserving, protecting and abiding the laws made by Government or that of Khaps. Word freedom is the most confusing word contextually. The real freedom is enjoyed by super rich and powerful class and the super poor class of society. There is one more poor class of society which is now categorized as neo-middle class. From where these terminologies come? This is the resultant intervention of laws and law maker in social life of common man. Why debates concerned with law and order are highly inclusive. Few educated people make rules and regulation for specific crimes and for generalized population.
The congruent point in celebrated freedom and restricted choices under the remit of Law of Land need to be redefined with utmost simplicity. Words acknowledged by the men in khaki with stick in hand can create fear momentary but cannot make people abide. Choices are infinite. Choice can be anything. Who will delimit the choices? Law of land should not define the behavioral conduct. Culture is unanimity of difference in choice. In democratic society like India, voices must be raised, heard and addressed.  Issues must be debated, devoid of diatribe features. If micro mini or anything which uncovers body instead of covering can be a choice then choices are open for those also who objectify women in item numbers and erotic advertisement. As used by sensor authorities the phrase “good taste” is a very vague and delicate term, and can be easily victimized by highly commercialized creativity.  Consequently, you have songs in which heroine says “I am the Tandoori Chiken meant to be consumed with Alcohol”. Don’t forget those ads in which girls go crazy after a boy by smelling a perfume he used on himself. Amazingly, all these are of good taste and that’s why these are broadcasted. This is also a matter of choice for the audience. But do they have any choice if they continuously bombarded with the same erotic audio visual? Do people of India have a choice to understand freedom with rights and duties of a citizen in context of the Law of Land? 


Rahul, Rajnath and Rajneeti




Unchallenged selection of leaders to lead parties who leads world’s largest democracy

This is the irony of Indian polity that politician who are sung as future leaders are selected unopposed from their respective party. One can say that political dynasty is still governed by the principal of passing on the throne, to the son king own. It is the season of turmoil and reshuffles in political leadership. Till now only twice the very reserved post of vice president is utilized in congress. Rahul Gandhi is third to sworn in as vice president of grand old congress. Party with difference BJP has been trying best to plaster up the cracks resulted because of ego clashes. Nitin Gadkari for whom BJP almost changed the party constitution replaced by the aggressive RSS man and former party president Rajnath Singh. In south DMK president MK Karunanidhi wants his younger son MK Stalin to take over leadership.  In Shiv Sena udhhav Thakre is now officially at helm of party. In Samajwadi Party Akhilesh Yadav is same as Rahul Gandhi for congress. There is no replacement or even stand by for Mayawati in BSP. At center it will be a fight of emotional Rahul VS hardliner Rajnath Singh.
Rahul who have been keeping mum after the failure in UP assembly elections delivered an emotional speech at Congress Chintan Shivar held in Jaipur. Rahul’s every single word was enriched with clamors from supporters. Rahul officially rewarded with more powers and so called responsibility, which he is enjoying since his arrival on political ground. Congress prince is being continuously alleged sarcastically by the rivals as where he stepped in for Congress, Congress loosed the ground devastatingly. Even the facts doest discourage voices which are against Rahul. Rahul Gandhi failed where ever he tried with full force, be it assembly elections of UP or Bihar. Despite of ups and downs congress and mother Sonia Gandhi is solidly standing with the new Vice President of Congress. Rahulji, as acknowledged by Congress president Sonia Gandhi holds a much more powerful stature then any of the post can empower. He is also given the responsibility to lead party in general election. Zeroing process on leadership issue for congress is much easier as it seems from outside. Rahul is future of congress with inevitable need and absolute compulsion. Congress voters will not imagine congress without a Gandhi member at the helm of national affairs. Rahul gave special mention to what her mother said to him. He said in his speech which was broadcasted live on all channels, that her mother came to him and told him that power comes with venom and mother cried. Rahuls narration made the congressmen teary. Rahul cried, Mother Sonia cried, senior leaders cried and the fresher’s cried. He emphasized that grassroots level worker must be respected and his problems should be heard and addressed. He advocated for changing the system which the whole nation wants, but why congress is preserving the issue for 2014. If that will is so genuine congress can began over hauling of government machinery in 2013. Rahul is immune to critical questions. He opted to stay quite on Anna agitation, Inflation, FDI, Cash Subsidy and on many scandals which happened in past few years. He didn’t spoke anything even on Delhi Gang Rape. Is he not moved when the UPA-2 was shaken up by the youth at Rajpath and India Gate. Social networking world goes on to comment that Rahul is perfect substitute to Manmohan Singh, who also prefers to stay quite. On the very first day of office at Akbar Road when mercury registered 5 c senior leaders wrapped in shawls stood up in queue to put garlands on the shoulders of new vice president as assuming to him PM returning from a foreign tour. Rahul ji was in cotton kurta and in regular jeans with sports shoes, as there is enough warmth of enthusiasm in his blood to pump zest in Grand old party of nation.    
Rajnath Singh is senior and respected leader of Bhartiya Janta Party. After a high voltage drama Rajnath Singh replaced Nitin Gadkari as party president. Nitin Gadkari who was alleged with charges of corruption in various cases is facing tremendous oppose not only from rivals but within the party. Top brass of BJP like L.K Advani, former Finance minister Yashwant Sinha, Ramjeth Malani never preferred RSS supported Nitin Gadkari as president for second term. Even the Hindutva poster boy and touted as BJPs popular option for PM candidate Narender Modi were in the league of oppose. On the other hand Narender Modi who got thumping majority to complete hat-rick in Gujarat is not accepted as candidate for PM by few senior leaders. BJP is rightly said as party with a difference. Just before the day when Rajnath Singh got second time lucky to lead BJP a tussle was going on between RSS and BJP over the second term for Nitin Gadkari. BJP’s senior most leader L K Advani was not in support of existing party president and RSS was not in mood think of non hindutva face. BJP was lacking leaders in the process. Just before the last day of filing nomination Yashwant Sinha asked for nomination papers to register clear oppose and indirect challenge for Nintin Gadkari. Sushma Swaraj and Arun Jaitly with soft image were not acceptable to RSS. Rajnath Singh being a pro-hindutva leader was an obvious choice. With heavy heart Nitin Gadkari have to make way out or himself and in for Rajnath Singh. Unlike Rahul Gandhi, experienced and aggressive Rajnath Singh declared his intention in the sworn in speech. He strongly condemned Home Ministers statement Saffron Terrorism. He announced for nationwide protest against government in leadership of Shushma Swaraj. Devoid of masses protest was not that big as people have seen in recent past. It was actually the announcement of arrival of hardliner Rajnath Singh.
This is interesting in political parties leaders are chosen unopposed. In the largest democracy of World there is no open method for selection of leaders at the helm within the party. It is general applicability that there is dearth of leaders who rise for grass root level. Leaders in super secured zone who travel in bullet proof Vehicles can be leader of masses. Media convener or popularly known as spokes person does the all talking. Leaders who are projected as mass leaders during election seasons hardly have seen taking head on questions. No one remembers when Rahul have given popular speech in anywhere not even in Loksabha. The famous Kalawati speech of Rahul during nuclear deal did have some impressions in media and in public. Even that speech was full of emotions. Rajnath Singh who does carry aggressive image has yet to rise above acclaimed hindutva trademark.

Monday, January 14, 2013

Essential drugs will be cheaper now



On November 22, 2012, Cabinet approved the new national pharmaceutical policy which will bar the
rising prices essential medicines. There are 348 medicines which are enlisted in the National
List of Essential Medicines. The new drug policy will restrict the manufacturer from selling
the essential medicines which are used by the majority of population in India with high profit
margins. It is also expected that with implementation of new policy prices of drugs will be
slashed by 50% to 80%. Indian pharmaceutical market which is world’s third largest in terms of
volume has given mixed responses to the new drug policy.

At present Ministry of chemicals and fertilizers controls the prices of only 74 essential drugs
which were 347 in 1979 when the first time Drug Pricing Control Order was implemented. The
idea of drug price controlling was inspired from the concept of essential medicines formulated by
World Health Organization in 1977. Latest approved policy will allow the government to control
the prices of 40% of the drugs sold in India. The Supreme Court of India in October this year
after hearing PIL filed by a NGO (All India Drug Action Network) asked the government to set
up a drug price regulation mechanism. In response to the directions of apex court a GoM was
also formed headed by Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar. Pharmaceutical industry took this
decision with mixed response but with a common concern that it will encourage disinvestment.
Indian Pharmaceutical Alliance (IPA) Secretary General told PTI that industry profit will
come down to Rs 4000 crore from Rs 67,500 crore. However, credit rating agency ICRA have
expected long term profits for multinational companies in the purview of new drug policy.

The health services which has been critically ill and of poor quality. Moreover, costly medicines
hits sharply to the hard earned saving of a common man. Government which falls way short in
providing basic amenities like proper public health care systems have finally took a reformist
decision. Market experts are eying this as a sort of relief when the escalating prices of all most
everything are burning the pockets of common man.

Unique Identification Numbers for Common Citizen



A Conundrum reply to age old administrative problems

Post 9/11 terrorist attack it was considered that having an identity proof can curb the growth
of terrorism. It was said that terrorist comes with Ak-47 not with identity proof. However,
the reality was bitter behind the curtains. Super power nation USA suffered the terrorism like
never before, the identity proof security flopped. Technical solution are impactful but in limited
space. The concept of Unique Identification number in India for every citizen is a huge project
because of its cost and impact. The ruling UPA made this project pro-poor scheme. Government
officials is singing about the advantages of this project that it will help to manage efficiently
welfare schemes such as the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (NREGA), the public
distribution system (PDS), public health and financial inclusion. Whereas, the London School
of Economics in UK and IIM-Ahmadabad in respect to India have questioned the utility of
project under Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) led by former CEO of Infosys
Nandan Nilekani.

In India thoughts for unique identity came after the Kargil war. After war, Kargil Review
Committee recommended the formula of ID cards to curb the infiltration in border areas. In
2003, NDA government launched “National Population Register” (NPR) and planned Multi-
purpose National Identity Card (MNIC). Since 2009, the same concept magnanimously operated
across the country. Till 25 October 2012 over 210 million people covering around 17% of total
population have been enrolled to UIDAI. Civil activist and retired Army officer Col. Mathew
Thomas said at a public consultation held in Bangalore last year that the functioning of UIDAI
in unconstitutional as the National Identification Authority of India Bill 2010 is still not cleared
from parliament. The future of UIDAI will remain uncertain in the absence legal powers. Public
distribution system will improve as targeted in the frame work of Unique Identification System is
also questioned by the Col. Mathew Thomas. He explained BPL families are dependent on ration
shopkeeper’s kindness and the shopkeeper can cheat with the card holder on the grounds of
authentication. Even bigger and unaddressed issue is of Identity theft. Developed countries that
already used such unique identity systems have no answer to identity thefts. There is no profound
and worldwide accepted safety system suggested by UIDAI. Many experts like Professor Ian
Angle from London School of Economics termed the UID system as “Olympics games of
hacking” on the data safety issues.

Besides all the controversies UID is the only and countries first nationwide accepted biometric
card which will carry all the crucial information of a citizen. If all went well UID seems to be
effective in curbing corruption at various levels by plugging the administrative leakages. At the
least one nation one identity issue will be solved. Goals linked with UID are very optimistic but
not impossible at all. Many policies and schemes which failed elsewhere have succeeded in India
UPA Government is hoping same.

Return of the ghost called FDI



Amidst controversies and oppose from outside the government, the Union Cabinet green singled
for foreign direct investment in different sectors. Despite of strong oppose from many allies,
UPA-2 moved ahead with the decision of allowing foreign investment of 51% in multi-brand
retail and 49% in aviation power exchange. Retail sectors giants such as Wall Mart, Tesco and
Carrefour are already enjoying Indian wholesale retail market in collaboration with Indian retail
companies.

With new economic reforms Government is all set to welcome foreign investors with open
arms. Now, it will be easier for foreign retailers to launch outlets in 51 cities with a minimum
population of 10 lakhs as per 2011 census. However, investment of minimum of $100 million
is must and out this, 50% must be utilized in establishment and development of backend
infrastructure as par new regulations. Central government played safe by making FDI optional
for states, considering the political stir against the FDI. Whereas, to cure the ailing aviation
sector, as per latest amendments foreign investors who are not associated with airline business
can buy up to 49% equity in Indian aviation companies. With Companies Bill, 2011 and Pension
Fund Regulatory and Development Authority Bill foreign investment in Insurance sector will be
now 49% from present 26%. To put the slowed Media industry on fast track government have
tried to boost the investment by increasing the cap of broadcasting service providers to 74% from
49%. This hike is for DTH service providers which will help in digitization of cable network and
in availing mobile television services. As per the Union cabinet’s decision TV news channels
and FM radio channels can draw the investment of 26% from foreign investors.

Foreign investment is less a part of economic reforms instead more of a political issue. Ruling
party is trying to convince common people and innocent voters to support FDI and vote for them
in coming elections and opposition is trying to turn the tide against the FDI. FDI is a frequently
debated issue which got its own political colors in India.

(Published In IAAN Express)

A Huge Setback for Community Radio



Ministry of Communication and Information Technology has quadrupled the royalty and
licence charges for community radio stations. In new regulations of the Wireless Planning
and Coordination (WPC) the operator has to pay Rs. 91,000 yearly instead of Rs 19700 for
broadcasting in the range of five to ten kilometres. In India there are 132 licensed community
radio stations which raise those issues which are under looked by the main stream media.
People who are operating community radio stations in India are either social worker or
NGOs. They are bounded by many broadcasting rules and regulations and have minimal
opportunity to raise fund to meet daily operational cost. Paying Rs 91,000 per annum as
royalty will be as bad as gagging the rural media. The rich and glamorised mainstream
media don’t have the space for rural and local issue. The community radio stations which are
covering news from grassroots will financially starve and eventually die because of this hike.

In 1990’s popular legal tussle between “Ministry of information and broadcasting” and
“Cricket association of Bengal” Supreme court said freedom of speech and expression also
include right to acquire and disseminate information and the airwaves are public property
which can be used be used for the benefit of society. This was a landmark decision which
have excited and encouraged those radio lovers and activist who wanted contribute in
development of society. In 2006, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting and Ministry of
communication worked in tandem to address the fundamental rights speech and expression
of communities making base article 19(1)(a) of the constitution. Community radios have
been successful in rural and remote areas for educating and awaking people at mass level
in a limited range. The success of such stations lies in the fact that it does not require
professionals whose motive is to run a station to earn profit. Radio enthusiast gets platform
to address people of their locality in the local language with via such non profitable radio
stations. The results which AIR and Doordarshan produced in the era of green revolution
and in later decades, is similar but of lesser impact as achieved by community radio stations.
But the hiked licence charges by government have literally discouraged and indirectly
barred community radio operators. Community Radio Forum (CRF) of India wrote to the
I&B minister Kapil Sibbal to reconsider his decision. Just hiked licence charges is not the
issue which should be addressed by the I&B but the whole set of new regulation which also
insist to give a bank guarantee of Rs 25000 while seeking a new licence. With the financial
hurdles, a new licence seeker should also have to get clearance from Standing Committee of
Frequency Allocation (SACFA), Wireless Operating Licence (WOL) and so on.

The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) in a position paper has once
recommended zero spectrum fees for community radio stations. However, instead of
supporting those who want to work for community development via mass media platform
government have made the road narrower then ever. Government should utilise community
radio stations as resource for development not for earning few pennies. Schemes like
ADHAR, MNREGA can be implemented more advantageously with proper communication
channels like community radio stations which are totally non-commercial. Government
can bank on the community radio stations for rural and community development instead of
bankrupting them.

(Published In IAAN Express)

Followers